A Tuscan Restaurant with a Story: St. Gregory Tentazione in Arezzo

St. Gregory Tentazione is a small bistrot on Via Fiorentina in Arezzo, where Lucia Margotti leads the kitchen and Marco Cacioli looks after the dining room and chooses the wines. There’s a personal feel to the place, and after spending an evening at their table, I came away impressed by what the two of them are doing and curious about how they got started.

From Bricklaying to a 14-Seat Bistrot

Marco started out as a bricklayer and worked in restaurants on weekends. Cooking was what interested him most, and he eventually decided to pursue it full time. He taught himself through books, the internet and experience in restaurant kitchens, spending much of his time researching ingredients and wine.

He opened his first restaurant in 2015 and turned it into a pub during the pandemic. In 2021, wanting to return to the kind of cooking he had done at his first restaurant, he opened St. Gregory Tentazione. The new bistrot had just 14 seats, and in the beginning Marco cooked the dishes and brought them out to the tables himself, sometimes with the help of his parents. Lucia joined him in 2024, after he had given up the pub, and now heads the kitchen. Their paths into cooking were similar. Both are self-taught and have developed their skills through research, experimentation and years of hands-on work.

On the Menu, from Galicia to the Casentino

We chose the five-course Rubia Gallega tasting menu (€80 per person), which brings Galician beef together with Tuscan Cinta Senese pork and porcini. I liked how Lucia worked the beef into several courses, from Rubia sausage with Cetica potato and porcini to the beef reduction glazing a tortellone filled with Cinta Senese. The main course was the heart of a ribeye from the Vicentico Extra selection, served with mushrooms and patate cristallo. As Marco explained at the table, the beef came from a cross between Wagyu and Rubia Gallega.

The four-course Signature menu (€60 per person) gives a broader look at the kitchen. It includes a filled tagliatella with Grigio del Casentino pork and Hungarian Mangalica ham, followed by duck with orange, passion fruit and mango. Both tasting menus are served to the whole table. À la carte, starters and first courses are mostly in the low to mid €20s, while main courses range from €34 to €42.

A Casentino Pinot Nero and a Few Pours from Marco’s Cellar

Marco’s wine list is very well chosen, with plenty of interesting bottles to try. We had Cuna’s Brendino 2020, a Pinot Nero from vines grown at more than 500 metres above sea level in the nearby Casentino hills. I’m always happy to find a wine from close to home on a list, especially a Casentino Pinot Nero. Marco generously poured us a few other wines from his cellar, and talking through them with him was one of my favorite parts of the evening. He knows his wines well, and you can tell how much he enjoys sharing them.

St. Gregory Tentazione Bistrot

Address: Via Fiorentina 239/241, 52100 Arezzo (AR), Italy
Tel: +39 0575 042657
Website: https://www.stgregorybistrot.it/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/stgregorybistrot/